Current Cybersecurity Demands in Banking RFPs

Introduction

Cybersecurity has become a non-negotiable priority in financial services procurement, with banks and credit unions mandating stringent vendor security assessments in RFPs. A 2023 report by PYMNTS and BNY Mellon found that 92% of financial institutions now require third-party vendors to meet SOC 2 Type II or ISO 27001 certifications before contract awards. This reflects heightened regulatory scrutiny from the FFIEC, EBA, and other global bodies enforcing cybersecurity frameworks like NIST CSF.

1. Regulatory-Driven Security Clauses

Recent RFPs from institutions like JPMorgan Chase and ING explicitly reference compliance with:

- FFIEC CAT (Cybersecurity Assessment Tool)

- DORA (EU Digital Operational Resilience Act)

- NYDFS Part 500 (for U.S. institutions)

Example from a 2023 Credit Union RFP (Alliant Credit Union):

“Vendors must provide full audit logs of system access controls, penetration test results from the last 12 months, and documented incident response plans aligned with NIST SP 800-61.”

2. Technical Requirements

Procurement teams now scrutinize:

- Zero-trust architecture implementation

- Data encryption standards (AES-256 or higher)

- Third-party risk management (e.g., vendor security scores via platforms like SecurityScorecard)

Trend Insight: The Bank of England’s 2024 fintech RFP mandated real-time threat intelligence feeds integrated with existing SIEM systems, signaling a shift toward proactive monitoring.

Vendor Response Strategies

✅ Must-Have Documentation

Fintechs should prepare:

1. Certification decks: SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001, or PCI DSS attestations

1. Questionnaire responses: Standardized formats like CAIQ (Consensus Assessments Initiative Questionnaire) from Cloud Security Alliance

1. Architecture diagrams: Highlighting encryption, data flows, and access controls

❌ Common Pitfalls to Avoid

- Generic responses (e.g., “We follow best practices” without evidence)

- Overlooking subprocessor risks (e.g., AWS/GCP compliance alone isn’t sufficient)

Best Practices for Procurement Teams

1. Weighted Scoring: Allocate 30–40% of RFP evaluation points to cybersecurity (sample scoring template below):

Criteria	Weight	Vendor A	Vendor B
Certifications	20%	95	70
Pen Test Results	15%	85	90
Incident Response Time	10%	80	60

1. Live Assessments: Conduct tabletop exercises during vendor shortlisting to test breach response protocols.

Future Trends & Takeaways

- AI-Powered Vendor Screening: Tools like BitSight and Black Kite are being integrated into RFP processes for automated risk scoring.

- ESG-Aligned Security: RFPs now link cybersecurity to broader ESG goals (e.g., BNP Paribas’ 2024 requirement for carbon-neutral data centers).

Actionable Tip: Vendors should monitor EU Tenders (TED) and SAM.gov for RFP language trends. A recent ECB tender emphasized quantum-resistant cryptography requirements—a growing differentiator.

For procurement teams, aligning cybersecurity demands with FFIEC CAT maturity tiers ensures consistency, while vendors must pre-package security evidence to accelerate evaluations. The gap between compliance and demonstrable resilience will define competitive advantage in 2024’s fintech RFPs.

References:

- Sample Bank RFP Security Annex (FFIEC)

- EU DORA Compliance Guidelines

FintechRFPs.com offers a curated library of professionally written RFP and RFI templates tailored for the fintech, banking, and payments industries. Whether you’re preparing responses for compliance, API integrations, cybersecurity, or core banking solutions, our templates help you save time, reduce errors, and improve your win rate with procurement teams and institutional buyers.

Respond Smarter and Faster with FintechRFPs.com Templates

Take the next step: explore our growing collection of fintech-specific RFP templates and boost your bid quality—visit FintechRFPs.com today.